Best 4-5 Cup Coffee Maker

Have you been looking for the Best 4-5 Cup Coffee Maker, I’ve compiled this detailed guide with some of the best options available this year, along with all the pros, cons, and overall reviews.

If you’re in a rush, Here I have picked out the top choice for your small coffee maker with auto shut off, as well as the best option if you are on a budget:

Best 4 to 5 Cup Coffee Maker: DCC-450BK by Cuisinart (Latest Price on Amazon)

Best budget overall: Amazon Basics coffee maker – 5 Cup (Latest Price on Amazon)

But if you’re up for some advanced analysis for all the available options on the market, keep reading this article as I’ll help you discover the perfect fit to fuel your coffee addiction!

Best 4-5 Cup Coffee Maker

Take a look through this list to know more about the top choices and why they were handpicked.

1. DCC-450BK by Cuisinart – 4 Cup

5 Cup Coffee Maker

The DCC-450BK coffee maker by Cuisinart is a robust little coffee machine that brews a nice cup of steamy hot coffee. Its simplistic, compact design and practical features make it my top pick for a 4-cup coffee maker.

The Cuisinart DCC-450BK coffee maker comes with a Stainless-steel carafe and takes up less counter space due to its small size, it also includes a variety of different features.

A couple of its most relevant functions include the ability to brew multiple cups of coffee at a time and a brew-pause feature which, as it suggests, pauses the brewing process of your coffee at any point you want.

Coming at a relatively decent price, this coffee maker just so happens to be one of the best machines available on the market, and perfect for you if you’re on a budget.

So, let’s take a look at some of its pros and cons…


• Fast brewing

• Compact design

• 30 min automatic shut off

• Has a “brew-pause” function

• Easy to clean

• Highly durable


• You can’t see the coffee whilst it’s brewing

• The coffee pot lid is hard to open.

• Only available to purchase in Two colors

• Doesn’t come with a filter

What people say:

The main points gathered for this coffee maker suggest that the machine is durable, is a decent size, and makes a delicious cup of coffee. However, several people also think that the machine was difficult to get used to, and some said that the machine needed better functionality; one of the main points being that due to the carafe and water tank not being see-through, it was hard to tell when they were properly filled or needed refilling.

2. KRUPS Simply Brew – 5 Cup

5 Cup Coffee Maker5 Cup Coffee Maker

If you’re looking for a 5-cup coffee maker that will pause mid-brew and keeps your coffee warm after brewing, then I would say, look no further.

KRUPS Simply Brew 5 Cup Coffee maker is known to be a small magical coffee maker that will allow you to get the most out of your fresh beans.

This coffee machine extracts as much flavor as possible whilst brewing your coffee, supplying you with a flavorsome taste.

KRUPS Simply Brew 5 Cup Coffee maker will keep your coffee warm for 30min and is also dishwasher safe.


• Keep Warm Feature

• Stainless steel

• Easy to use

• Compact design


• Deep receptacle makes it hard to clean

• Carafe design makes it hard to pour.

What people say:

From looking at the reviews for this coffee maker I have summarized that the main points customers have made are that this machine brews flavorful coffee.

However, there were also a few people that reported there being spillage and pour spout leakage issues. It might very well be a problem related to a specific production lot, but it remains important not to disregard.

There you have it! These model options are the best 4-Cup makers the market has to offer.

There are many great choices of small coffee makers that I will detail below. so if you don’t mind going a cup higher, here below are my top picks for 5 cup coffee makers with an automatic shut off feature.

3. CGX7-RB by Mr. Coffee – 5 Cup

The Mr. Coffee CGX7-RB is an affordable small coffee machine that has easy-to-use controls and is perfect for someone new to coffee makers. Its programmable feature makes it the perfect, high-tech coffee maker for any and all coffee lovers who want a quick and delicious cup of coffee in the morning.

This compact design coffee maker features a pause function, programmable options, an automatic shut-off, and a reusable filter – so no need to waste your money on paper products.


• Programmable

• 1-hour auto shut off

• Simple controls

• Easy to clean

• Easy to fill water


• Glass container not strong enough.

• Doesn’t keep the coffee hot for long.

• Slower brew time.

What people say:

Although most of the reviews for this coffee maker were positive, suggesting that it was an easy-to-use, perfect budget coffee maker for the kitchen, some of the reviews weren’t as supportive of this little machine. There were a few complaints of the machine breaking after a couple of uses, some customers even going as far to say that it just wasn’t worth the money.

4. Kenmore 80509 Digital Coffee Maker5 Cup

The Kenmore 80509 Digital coffee maker is an affordable, stunning model that brews up to 5 cups of coffee at a time.

It features an automatic shut-off function of 2 hours, and what makes this coffee maker significantly more advanced than most other coffee makers is the fact that it uses a metal filter, containing absolutely no paper products.

Like most smaller coffee makers on the market, this 5 cup coffee maker has a pause and Serve function that allows you to pause the brewing process and grab a delicious cup of coffee before it’s completely finished brewing.

It also has a 24-hour programmable control feature that you can set just before you go to bed so that when you wake up in the morning your senses are instantly filled with the wonderful smell of freshly brewed coffee.


• Automatic Shut-off feature

• Programmable controls

• Pause and serve function

• Brews up to 5 cups of coffee

• Permanent Metal filter


• A bit of a bigger and bulkier design

• Spillage could occur.

What people say:

After taking a look at the reviews for this product, I have discovered that the main points customers have made after purchasing this coffee maker are that the machine makes quite a decent cup of coffee, it brews fast and it’s relatively easy to clean.

However, some customer reviews also reported that the heating element was flawed in the sense that it brewed coffee too hot, making it almost taste burnt sometimes. A few customers also noted that the size was slightly inconvenient due to its bulkiness.

5. Mr. Coffee 2129512, 5-Cup Mini Brew

5 Cup Coffee Maker5 Cup Coffee Maker

If you’re looking for a more compact coffee maker, then the Mr. Coffee might be the perfect coffee maker for you. Although this coffee machine is small in size, it still provides you with all the same functions as some of the bigger, bulky-looking ones.

The Mr. Coffee Mini has a wide range of fancy functions such as the automatic shut off (after 2 hours), as well as the ‘grab a cup’ auto pause feature which is great for when you simply can’t wait any longer for that hot, deliciously refreshing beverage.


• Compact to fit on smaller surfaces

• Pause function

• ‘Grab a cup’ feature


• Average quality

What people say:

The main points customers have mentioned about this machine are that it is easy to clean, long-lasting, and very simple. On the other hand, some of the bad reviews also heavily suggested that the overall taste of the coffee wasn’t that great, some customers noting a ‘plastic’ or ‘watery’ taste.

6. Amazon Basics coffee maker – 5 Cup

5 Cup Coffee Maker

Perfect for if you’re on a budget, the Amazon Basics 5 cup coffee maker comes for quite an affordable price. and it contains all of the features of some of the more expensive options on the market.

Amazon is a widely known online platform for buying practically anything you want, but they also have their own product line which includes this stunning coffee maker.

One of the best features that I will note about the Amazon Basics 5 cup coffee maker is that if you grow impatient and just want that delicious smelling coffee right away, the machine will automatically shut-down the moment you remove the carafe, even if the coffee is not fully done brewing yet!

Another notable feature of this coffee maker is that there is no need to waste money buying countless filter replacements, all you need to do is wash the same filter it comes with, and reuse it again – Another thing that makes this coffee maker the perfect budget choice!


• Affordable

• Brews up to 5 cups

• Reusable filter

• Able to stop mid-brew


• Not many button options

• Hand wash carafe only

What people say:

Given its low price, you might not expect much from this machine. However, the majority of the customer reviews praised the Amazon Basics 5 cup coffee maker quite a bit.

Some of the main points made by the customers were that the machine was easy to clean, made a great-tasting brew, and it was the perfect, compact size to fit anywhere in the kitchen.

Another thing is that if you own an Amazon Echo, then you can use a smart plug to activate your coffee machine by voice control. On the other hand, there were a few reviews that stated the machine was a bit basic, and only really has one button – on/off.

7. BV1500TS by Bonavita – 5 Cup

5 Cup Coffee Maker

If you’re looking for a coffee machine that’s going to keep your coffee steaming hot for a long time, then the Bonavita BV1500TS might be for you.

The carafe on most coffee makers are either made from plastic or glass, however, the carafe for the Bonavita BV1500TS is made out of stainless steel, keeping your coffee at the perfect temperature for a longer time.

This coffee maker is a little more on the expensive side, but for good reason.

Although this coffee maker is not programmable, it has a wide range of different options to choose from, including an option to have the roasted coffee beans saturated and degassed before brewing for a much stronger taste in your coffee – this will only take a couple of extra minutes, too!

As well as this, along with the carafe being thermal, the carafe lid, filter basket, and coffee dispenser are all dishwasher safe, making it extremely easy to clean.


• Thermal Stainless Steel carafe

• Fast brewing

• Simple to use and intuitive

• Dishwasher safe

• Automatic shut off


• Very hard to fill the water reservoir due to its lid design.

• Can leave excess drops in the carafe after pouring

What people say:

The reviews for this product stated that although the stainless steel, the thermal carafe is indeed great for keeping the coffee hot, it is also a bit ‘awkward’ to pour, and it tends to leave behind the last drops of coffee due to its design.

Other than this, the majority of the customers seemed to only have good words for this product, some of the main points being that it is easy to use, easy to clean, and makes a great cup of coffee.

8. Chefman Grind and brew, (We Have removed this item From our list)

Another one of my top 4-cup coffee makers with automatic shut off is the Chefman Grind 4 Cup Coffee Maker. This machine allows you to use freshly ground coffee beans for your brew, whilst also allowing you to select which strength option you would like for your coffee.

Compared to most other coffee makers on the market, the Chefman Grind 4 Cup Coffee Maker has a very different, unique design and will fit almost anywhere.

Although this machine is another one that leans more towards the expensive side, if you have the budget for it, its grind and brew functionality is worth it.


• Unique design

• Pause brew feature

• 30-minute automatic shut off

• Built-in grinder


• Not durable for its price.

• Difficult to wash

• Takes very long to dry out.

• Doesn’t have a programmable timer

What people say:

The customer reviews for this product suggested that the machine made a delicious tasting brew due to the freshly ground beans and that its small design was perfect for almost anywhere. On the downside, a lot of the customers also commented on the fact that although it’s not a major issue, this machine was particularly hard to clean.

Final Thoughts

So, that’s all of the best small coffee makers with automatic shut off. Hopefully, you found the perfect machine for you with the help of this list!

Make sure to check out some of the other coffee-dedicated articles here and share this article with your friends and social media so that you can help them find the perfect coffee maker, too!

Don’t forget to leave a comment with your thoughts!

Similar Posts